Mary tending to her fantastical garden

Mary Mary Quite Contrary

Mary, Mary, quite contrary,
How does your garden grow?
With silver bells and cockle shells,
And pretty maids all in a row.

Listen as female British:

Listen as male American:

Visited 9 times, 1 visit(s) today

Posted in All Rhymes, Daily Life & Objects, Historical & Legendary, Mother Goose Classics, Nature & Seasons, Songs & Verses

Tagged cockle shells, garden, maid, Mary, mysterious, silver bells

Subscribe

0 Comments

Oldest

Newest Most Voted

Inline Feedbacks

View all comments

Meaning

Outwardly, this rhyme playfully asks how Mary’s garden grows, with an imaginative and fanciful answer involving “silver bells,” “cockle shells,” and “pretty maids.” For children, it conjures a magical, mysterious garden full of unknown wonders, stimulating creativity and imaginative play.

Origin

First printed in 1744 in Tommy Thumb’s Pretty Song Book, the rhyme is centuries old and firmly rooted in English oral tradition. Theories about its meaning abound—some believe “Mary” refers to Mary I of England (“Bloody Mary”), others to Mary, Queen of Scots, or the Virgin Mary, while some see it as simple garden imagery with no hidden meaning.

Time Period

Widely published from the mid-18th century onward, this rhyme remains a staple in English-speaking nursery rhyme collections and children’s games.

Why It Became Popular

The rhyme’s simple structure, easy-to-memorize rhythm, and playful language made it a classroom and playground classic. Children enjoy acting it out, imagining or drawing the mysterious items—bells, shells, and rows of “maids.”

Structure and Style

Meter: Trochaic, regular and musical
Rhyme Scheme: AABB
Line Count: 4 (in the standard version)
Style Notes: Question-and-answer, vivid visual imagery, succinct

Themes

Imagination and fantasy
Gardens and nature
Mystery and speculation
Puzzle or riddle

Language Notes

The rhyme’s unusual answer has invited endless speculation—“silver bells” and “cockle shells” may be flowers, garden decorations, Catholic references, or simply fanciful. “Pretty maids” might be flowers (like primroses or daisies) or refer to rows of girls, dolls, or attendants.

Moral or Lesson

While no overt moral is stated, the rhyme encourages curiosity and questioning, as well as imaginative problem-solving in interpreting meaning.

Historical or Cultural Notes

Explanations range from religious and historical allegory (Catholic implements, English queens, or courtly references) to simple nursery fun. “Mary” may be a veiled reference to controversial figures, but most scholars agree that any such symbolism is unproven. The rhyme’s playful puzzle survives because it invites multiple interpretations.

Notable Variants

Lines like “And so my garden grows,” “Cowslips all in a row,” or “Marigolds all in a row” sometimes replace the familiar ending. Early versions use “Mistress Mary” or “Mrs. Mary” for the opening line.

Appearances in Media or Literature

Included in every major nursery rhyme collection; referenced and parodied in novels, children’s books, and visual art. Variants appear in The Secret Garden and many classic Mother Goose editions.

Suggested Activities

Imaginative Drawing: Illustrate “Mary’s garden” with bells, shells, creative flowers, and “maids.”
Pretend Garden: Arrange objects or dolls “all in a row” to act out the rhyme.
History Detective: Explore the possible historical Marys and symbols in the rhyme.
Riddle Games: Write new verses about what might be in Mary’s garden.
Garden Activities: Plant seeds or start a classroom garden, linking it to the rhyme.

0

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x

()